Have a look:
These questions are asking for legal advice. For obvious reasons, I think we should decline to answer these. Opinions?
Have a look:
These questions are asking for legal advice. For obvious reasons, I think we should decline to answer these. Opinions?
I think these questions are common enough, and information about them important enough, that we shouldn't back away from them entirely. However, for the same obvious reasons you refer to, perhaps we can develop some rules / caveats. For example:
My experience on SO and the other Exchange sites has been that the community can be effective at shaping how questions are asked and answered. Legal questions are a common and crucial part of Q&A for writers, and if this is going to become a premiere community for writers the way SO has for programmers, we'd do better to handle these questions with a steady hand on the rudder than to tell people to take them elsewhere.
In reference to this question, and @MarkBaker 's comments on the accepted answer: If I write a scene almost exactly like in someone's photograph, would it be plagiarism?
I think the answer to this meta question ("are legal questions on topic") should be "no." Most of us are not qualified to give legal advice, so our answers will always be opinion based. My vote is that we declare legal questions off-topic, for our own protection.